The article "Darkness Too
Visible" by Megan Cox Gurden is about how young adult books are too
inappropriate for young adult readers. Things like depression and murder are
included in books aimed for teens. Some people believe that books with these themes
and issues should not be a part of young adult fiction books. The author is
trying to show that young adult books are tackling topics that may be less
appropriate for the targeted age group.
The author wants to make the
reader feel like the young adult books should be taken off the book shelves.
The author used Amy Freeman, a mother of three, as an example, she went
to a book store the find a young adult book for her 13 year old daughter, but
found nothing, "It was all vampires and suicide and self-mutilation, all
this dark, dark stuff." (pg.1) To parents, these topics are thought of as
bad and unwanted for their children. The author also goes on tho say that
"...a careless young reader-or one who seeks out depravity-will find himself
surrounded by images not of joy or beauty, but of damage, brutality and losses
of the most horrendous kinds." (pg.1) Young adult books are portrayed as
negative, gory, and gruesome. The author used her opinion on young adult books
to try and persuade the reader to think negatively towards young adult books.
The author views young adult
books as negative. I believe that young adult books are readable to young
readers. Readers are the ones who decide whether or not to read the books, so
the readers are at fault if they find the book scary not the author of the
book. These gory and somewhat nasty books may seem scary, but there is always
something to take from them. They show the true nature of things and how to
react to things like that if they happen in real life.
When you said "the readers are at fault if they find the book scary not the author of the book", I thought that you were right, and it depends on whether or not the reader finds the book scary.
ReplyDeleteGreat job Angela! I love you claim and how you supported it!
ReplyDelete